City data dated
11 American Restaurants in Bensonhurst West
Abby's Coffee Shop was inspected most recently, on October 6, 2026.
Black Horses Tavern shows a B. 9 show an A. 1 has no letter right now.
3 of the 11 are on New Utrecht Ave, and 2 more on 18th Ave.
The 11, A to Z
| No. | Name | Address | Phone | Grade | Inspected |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Abby's Coffee Shop | 7310 20th Ave | (347) 374-5342 | Grade A | Oct 6, 2026 |
| 2 | Bay Bagels | 6302 Bay Pkwy | (718) 975-3123 | Grade A | Aug 15, 2025 |
| 3 | Black Horses Tavern | 7507 New Utrecht Ave | (929) 481-9833 | Grade B | Jun 19, 2026 |
| 4 | Butcher's Burger | 7501 New Utrecht Ave | (347) 893-0443 | Grade A | Dec 4, 2024 |
| 5 | Five Guys Burgers and Fries | 1628 Shore Pkwy | (914) 643-2180 | Grade A | Nov 20, 2025 |
| 6 | Fuel Fever | 8615 18th Ave | (718) 259-8448 | Grade A | Sep 22, 2026 |
| 7 | Gus' American Grill | 7206 New Utrecht Ave | (718) 331-7573 | Grade A | Sep 9, 2025 |
| 8 | Hangover Burger | 2013 86th St | (646) 886-0901 | No letter | Oct 20, 2025 |
| 9 | New Dyker Restaurant | 8505 18th Ave | (718) 234-1435 | Grade A | Jul 7, 2026 |
| 10 | Subway | 6724 Bay Pkwy | (347) 492-3888 | Grade A | Oct 21, 2025 |
| 11 | Wendy's | 1602 Shore Pkwy | (718) 747-9002 | Grade A | Jan 22, 2026 |
Street by street
New Utrecht Ave 3
- Black Horses Tavern 7507 New Utrecht Ave
- Butcher's Burger 7501 New Utrecht Ave
- Gus' American Grill 7206 New Utrecht Ave
18th Ave 2
- Fuel Fever 8615 18th Ave
- New Dyker Restaurant 8505 18th Ave
Bay Pkwy 2
- Bay Bagels 6302 Bay Pkwy
- Subway 6724 Bay Pkwy
Shore Pkwy 2
- Five Guys Burgers and Fries 1628 Shore Pkwy
- Wendy's 1602 Shore Pkwy
One each: Abby's Coffee Shop on 20th Ave, Hangover Burger on 86th St.
American Restaurants in Bensonhurst West: questions
- How many American restaurants are in Bensonhurst West?
- 11 filed as American with at least one inspection, as of October 30, 2026. Owners pick their own label, so 3 more filed as Hamburgers aren't in this count.
- What is the best American restaurant in Bensonhurst West?
- 9 of 11 show an A, and the newest A went to Abby's Coffee Shop on October 6, 2026. That letter covers food safety at the last graded inspection. This file has no ratings or reviews, so we don't pick a favorite.
- Which American restaurants in Bensonhurst West have an A grade?
- Abby's Coffee Shop, Bay Bagels, Butcher's Burger, Five Guys Burgers and Fries, Fuel Fever, Gus' American Grill, New Dyker Restaurant, Subway, and Wendy's.
- Do any American restaurants in Bensonhurst West have a B or C?
- Yes. Black Horses Tavern shows a B from December 17, 2024.
- Which street has the most American restaurants in Bensonhurst West?
- New Utrecht Ave, with 3: Black Horses Tavern, Butcher's Burger, and Gus' American Grill.
- Are all 11 open right now?
- The file has no hours, and a place can close months before it drops off. All of them have a phone number on file, so call before you go.
Keep looking
American next door
Other labels in Bensonhurst West
Citywide
- All American restaurants in NYC 4,775
- All of Brooklyn 1,045
- New American 217
- Hamburgers 497
- Steakhouse 105
Where this comes from
Names, addresses, phones, cuisine labels, grades and dates come from the DOHMH New York City Restaurant Inspection Results on NYC Open Data. The file behind this page is dated October 30, 2026, and its newest inspection is from October 29, 2026. We check for a new file every 24 hours. For the city's own lookup, use ABC Eats.