City data dated
7 Pizza Places in Coney Island & Sea Gate
Surf Pizza & Wings shows a C. S & M Pizza shows a B. 3 show an A. 2 have no letter right now.
3 of the 7 are on Mermaid Ave.
24 Brooklyn neighborhoods have more on file, out of 49 with any.
The 7, A to Z
| No. | Name | Address | Phone | Grade | Inspected |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Al Cavallino | 1615 Boardwalk West | (718) 373-5862 | No letter | Jun 18, 2022 |
| 2 | Papa John's Pizza | 2124 Mermaid Ave | (917) 302-6461 | Grade A | Nov 17, 2025 |
| 3 | Pizza on the Run | 1627 Mermaid Ave | (718) 946-6677 | Grade A | Jan 6, 2026 |
| 4 | Pizza on the Run | 2914 Stillwell Ave | (718) 513-0454 | Grade A | Apr 28, 2026 |
| 5 | S & M Pizza | 2726 Mermaid Ave | (347) 365-2706 | Grade B | Mar 26, 2024 |
| 6 | Surf Pizza & Wings | 2115 Surf Ave | (347) 462-9392 | Grade C | Feb 3, 2025 |
| 7 | Totonno's Pizzeria | 1524 Neptune Ave | (718) 372-8606 | No letter | Mar 28, 2026 |
Street by street
Mermaid Ave 3
- Papa John's Pizza 2124 Mermaid Ave
- Pizza on the Run 1627 Mermaid Ave
- S & M Pizza 2726 Mermaid Ave
One each: Al Cavallino on Boardwalk West, Totonno's Pizzeria on Neptune Ave, Pizza on the Run on Stillwell Ave, Surf Pizza & Wings on Surf Ave.
Pizza Places in Coney Island & Sea Gate: questions
- How many pizza places are in Coney Island & Sea Gate?
- 7 filed as Pizza with at least one inspection, as of October 30, 2026.
- What is the best pizza place in Coney Island & Sea Gate?
- 3 of 7 show an A, and the newest A went to Pizza on the Run on April 28, 2026. That letter covers food safety at the last graded inspection. This file has no ratings or reviews, so we don't pick a favorite.
- Which pizza places in Coney Island & Sea Gate have an A grade?
- Papa John's Pizza, Pizza on the Run, and Pizza on the Run.
- Do any pizza places in Coney Island & Sea Gate have a B or C?
- Yes. S & M Pizza shows a B from March 26, 2024. Surf Pizza & Wings shows a C from February 3, 2025.
- Which street has the most pizza places in Coney Island & Sea Gate?
- Mermaid Ave, with 3: Papa John's Pizza, Pizza on the Run, and S & M Pizza.
- Are all 7 open right now?
- The file has no hours, and a place can close months before it drops off. All of them have a phone number on file, so call before you go.
Keep looking
Pizza next door
Other labels in Coney Island & Sea Gate
- American 23
- Chinese 5
- Chicken 3
- Frozen Desserts 3
- Hotdogs 3
Citywide
- All pizza places in NYC 1,592
- All of Brooklyn 426
- Italian 1,006
Where this comes from
Names, addresses, phones, cuisine labels, grades and dates come from the DOHMH New York City Restaurant Inspection Results on NYC Open Data. The file behind this page is dated October 30, 2026, and its newest inspection is from October 29, 2026. We check for a new file every 24 hours. For the city's own lookup, use ABC Eats.