How many pizza places are in DUMBO, Vinegar Hill, Downtown Brooklyn & Boerum Hill?

21 filed as Pizza with at least one inspection, as of October 30, 2026. Owners pick their own label, so 12 more filed as Italian aren't in this count.

What is the best pizza place in DUMBO, Vinegar Hill, Downtown Brooklyn & Boerum Hill?

17 of 21 show an A, and the newest A went to Front Street Pizza on October 22, 2026. That letter covers food safety at the last graded inspection. This file has no ratings or reviews, so we don't pick a favorite.

Which street has the most pizza places in DUMBO, Vinegar Hill, Downtown Brooklyn & Boerum Hill?

4th Ave, with 3: 99 Cent Supreme Pizza, Brooklyn's Homeslice, and Papa John's.

Are all 21 open right now?

The file has no hours, and a place can close months before it drops off. All of them have a phone number on file, so call before you go.

City data dated October 30, 2026

21 Pizza Places in DUMBO, Vinegar Hill, Downtown Brooklyn & Boerum Hill

Front Street Pizza was inspected most recently, on October 22, 2026.

$1.50 Hot Pizza, Sotto Casa, and Supreme Pizza show a B. 17 show an A. 1 has no letter right now.

3 of the 21 are on 4th Ave, and 2 more on Front St.

17 A 3 B 0 C 1 no letterOne tile per place. A health grade covers the last graded inspection: food handling, temperatures, cleaning, pests. Taste isn't part of it.

A B C no letter subway station, with its daytime linesNumbers match the table below.

The 21, A to Z

Pizza Places in DUMBO, Vinegar Hill, Downtown Brooklyn & Boerum Hill, alphabetical
No.	Name	Address	Phone	Grade	Inspected
1	$1.50 Hot Pizza	255 Livingston St	(347) 884-5060	Grade B	Sep 10, 2025
2	99 Cent Supreme Pizza	22 4th Ave	(646) 427-4438	Grade A	Feb 12, 2026
3	99 Cents Supreme Pizza	44 Willoughby St	(347) 463-9595	Grade A	Oct 5, 2026
4	Alvo Pizza	150 Smith St	(315) 373-1769	Pending	Sep 23, 2026
5	Angelica Pizzeria	30 Nevins St	(718) 852-2728	Grade A	Sep 21, 2026
6	Brooklyn's Homeslice	42 4th Ave	(917) 279-7330	Grade A	Jan 23, 2026
7	Dekalb Pizzeria	445 Albee Sq	(917) 549-3308	Grade A	Sep 24, 2025
8	Domino's	146 Smith St	(718) 596-7000	Grade A	Jul 14, 2026
9	Fornino	55 Water St	(917) 743-7388	Grade A	Jul 8, 2026
10	Front Street Pizza	80 Front St	(718) 875-3700	Grade A	Oct 22, 2026
11	Grimaldi's Pizzeria	1 Front St	(718) 858-4300	Grade A	Jun 23, 2025
12	Ignazio's	4 Water St	(718) 522-2100	Grade A	Jan 27, 2026
13	Jay St Fresh 99 Cents Pizza	408 Jay St	(917) 353-6405	Grade A	Jun 5, 2025
14	Juliana's Pizza	19 Old Fulton St	(718) 596-6700	Grade A	Sep 16, 2026
15	Little Pizza Parlor	192 Duffield St	(347) 799-1249	Grade A	May 8, 2026
16	Norm's Pizza	345 Adams St	(917) 587-8888	Grade A	Sep 23, 2026
17	Papa John's	138 4th Ave	(718) 852-7272	Grade A	Oct 21, 2025
18	Papa John's Pizza	146 Lawrence St	(718) 596-7272	Grade A	Jun 3, 2026
19	Pronto Pizza	139 Court St	(718) 522-2225	Grade A	Jun 2, 2026
20	Sotto Casa	298 Atlantic Ave	(718) 852-8758	Grade B	Aug 24, 2026
21	Supreme Pizza	472 Fulton St	(646) 427-4438	Grade B	Mar 19, 2025

Street by street

4th Ave 3

99 Cent Supreme Pizza 22 4th Ave
Brooklyn's Homeslice 42 4th Ave
Papa John's 138 4th Ave

Front St 2

Front Street Pizza 80 Front St
Grimaldi's Pizzeria 1 Front St

Smith St 2

Alvo Pizza 150 Smith St
Domino's 146 Smith St

Water St 2

Fornino 55 Water St
Ignazio's 4 Water St

One each: Norm's Pizza on Adams St, Dekalb Pizzeria on Albee Sq, Sotto Casa on Atlantic Ave, Pronto Pizza on Court St, Little Pizza Parlor on Duffield St, Supreme Pizza on Fulton St, Jay St Fresh 99 Cents Pizza on Jay St, Papa John's Pizza on Lawrence St, $1.50 Hot Pizza on Livingston St, Angelica Pizzeria on Nevins St, Juliana's Pizza on Old Fulton St, 99 Cents Supreme Pizza on Willoughby St.

Pizza Places in DUMBO, Vinegar Hill, Downtown Brooklyn & Boerum Hill: questions

How many pizza places are in DUMBO, Vinegar Hill, Downtown Brooklyn & Boerum Hill?: 21 filed as Pizza with at least one inspection, as of October 30, 2026. Owners pick their own label, so 12 more filed as Italian aren't in this count.
What is the best pizza place in DUMBO, Vinegar Hill, Downtown Brooklyn & Boerum Hill?: 17 of 21 show an A, and the newest A went to Front Street Pizza on October 22, 2026. That letter covers food safety at the last graded inspection. This file has no ratings or reviews, so we don't pick a favorite.
Which pizza places in DUMBO, Vinegar Hill, Downtown Brooklyn & Boerum Hill have an A grade?: 99 Cent Supreme Pizza, 99 Cents Supreme Pizza, Angelica Pizzeria, Brooklyn's Homeslice, Dekalb Pizzeria, Domino's, Fornino, Front Street Pizza, Grimaldi's Pizzeria, Ignazio's, and 7 more.
Do any pizza places in DUMBO, Vinegar Hill, Downtown Brooklyn & Boerum Hill have a B or C?: Yes. $1.50 Hot Pizza shows a B from September 10, 2025. Sotto Casa shows a B from May 29, 2025. Supreme Pizza shows a B from March 19, 2025.
Which street has the most pizza places in DUMBO, Vinegar Hill, Downtown Brooklyn & Boerum Hill?: 4th Ave, with 3: 99 Cent Supreme Pizza, Brooklyn's Homeslice, and Papa John's.
Are all 21 open right now?: The file has no hours, and a place can close months before it drops off. All of them have a phone number on file, so call before you go.

Keep looking

Pizza next door

Other labels in DUMBO, Vinegar Hill, Downtown Brooklyn & Boerum Hill

All of DUMBO, Vinegar Hill, Downtown Brooklyn & Boerum Hill

Citywide

Where this comes from

Names, addresses, phones, cuisine labels, grades and dates come from the DOHMH New York City Restaurant Inspection Results on NYC Open Data. The file behind this page is dated October 30, 2026, and its newest inspection is from October 29, 2026. We check for a new file every 24 hours. For the city's own lookup, use ABC Eats.