How many sandwich shops are in Midtown & Midtown South?

36 filed as Sandwiches with at least one inspection, as of October 30, 2026. Owners pick their own label, so 10 more filed as Soups/Salads/Sandwiches and 22 more filed as Sandwiches/Salads/Mixed Buffet aren't in this count.

What is the best sandwich shop in Midtown & Midtown South?

31 of 36 show an A, and the newest A went to Subway on October 22, 2026. That letter covers food safety at the last graded inspection. This file has no ratings or reviews, so we don't pick a favorite.

Which sandwich shops in Midtown & Midtown South have an A grade?

Alidoro, America Gourmet Food, Blake & Todd, Broad Nosh Bagels, Broad Street Deli, Cafe 37, Carve Unique Sandwiches, Casa Toscana, City Cafe, Corporate Chef Cafe & Catering, and 21 more.

Do any sandwich shops in Midtown & Midtown South have a B or C?

Yes. Gardenia Deli shows a B from June 5, 2023. Tsq Food Court shows a B from October 14, 2025.

Which street has the most sandwich shops in Midtown & Midtown South?

W 42nd St, with 4: Casa Toscana, Cheesesteaks by the Truffleist, Shake Shack Bryant Park, and Whoopie Company.

Are all 36 open right now?

The file has no hours, and a place can close months before it drops off. All of them have a phone number on file, so call before you go.

City data dated October 30, 2026

36 Sandwich Shops in Midtown & Midtown South

No other Manhattan neighborhood has more on file. The borough has 198 in all.

4 of the 36 are on W 42nd St, and 3 more on Broadway.

Gardenia Deli and Tsq Food Court show a B. 31 show an A. 3 have no letter right now.

31 A 2 B 0 C 3 no letterOne tile per place. A health grade covers the last graded inspection: food handling, temperatures, cleaning, pests. Taste isn't part of it.

A B C no letter subway station, with its daytime linesNumbers match the table below.

The 36, A to Z

Sandwich Shops in Midtown & Midtown South, alphabetical
No.	Name	Address	Phone	Grade	Inspected
1	Alidoro	1 Rockefeller Plaza	(646) 692-4330	Grade A	Oct 6, 2026
2	America Gourmet Food	831 6th Ave	(212) 868-9790	Grade A	Feb 3, 2026
3	Blake & Todd	7 W 47th St	(212) 869-1929	Grade A	Apr 21, 2026
4	Broad Nosh Bagels	36 E 58th St	(212) 355-3311	Grade A	Jun 25, 2026
5	Broad Street Deli	270 Park Ave	(917) 531-2269	Grade A	Apr 1, 2026
6	Cafe 37	47 W 37th St	(212) 391-1523	Grade A	Mar 18, 2026
7	Carve Unique Sandwiches	760 8th Ave	(212) 730-4949	Grade A	Mar 10, 2026
8	Casa Toscana	42 W 42nd St	(718) 607-8306	Grade A	Nov 28, 2023
9	Cheesesteaks by the Truffleist	42 W 42nd St	(917) 325-3374	No letter	Nov 28, 2023
10	City Cafe	35 W 43rd St	(212) 764-0444	Grade A	Sep 25, 2025
11	Corporate Chef Cafe & Catering	50 W 56th St	(212) 245-0056	Grade A	Oct 7, 2025
12	Gardenia Deli	404 8th Ave	(212) 736-5617	Grade B	Jun 5, 2023
13	Healthy Choice Gourmet Deli & Pizza	341 7th Ave	(212) 279-9221	Grade A	Apr 21, 2026
14	Holy Schnitzel	245 W 46th St	(212) 393-4659	No letter	Oct 21, 2026
15	Market Crates	26 W 33rd St	(212) 283-1991	Grade A	Jun 22, 2026
16	Matto Espresso	8 W 46th St	(917) 370-1955	Grade A	Feb 6, 2026
17	Mel & Toast	252 W 37th St	(732) 673-0922	No letter	Apr 3, 2024
18	The Picnic Basket	65 W 37th St	(212) 382-2627	Grade A	Oct 9, 2025
19	Potbelly	46 W 56th St	(646) 289-4210	Grade A	Jan 9, 2026
20	Potbelly	501 Fashion Ave	(646) 289-4205	Grade A	Jun 4, 2026
21	Pret a Manger	1350 6th Ave	(646) 609-3360	Grade A	Oct 8, 2025
22	Pret a Manger	1700 Broadway	(347) 846-8812	Grade A	Oct 5, 2026
23	Pret a Manger	1756 Broadway	(646) 964-4302	Grade A	Sep 23, 2026
24	The Shack - Cb8030 (Cb8040)	4 Penn Plaza	(212) 465-6273	Grade A	Feb 1, 2025
25	Shake Shack Bryant Park	120 W 42nd St	(646) 517-6142	Grade A	Aug 19, 2026
26	Subway	1400 Broadway	(215) 900-2003	Grade A	Aug 11, 2026
27	Subway	175 W 26th St	(929) 444-3643	Grade A	Oct 22, 2026
28	Subway	214 W 50th St	(212) 265-1822	Grade A	Mar 24, 2026
29	Subway	36 W 46th St	(212) 221-7565	Grade A	Apr 3, 2026
30	Subway	52 Vanderbilt Ave	(212) 673-2500	Grade A	May 13, 2025
31	Subway	830 7th Ave	(212) 315-5488	Grade A	Oct 19, 2026
32	The Tipsy Baker	30 Rockefeller Plaza	(646) 669-7575	Grade A	Oct 6, 2026
33	Tsq Food Court	163 W 48th St	(212) 933-0966	Grade B	Apr 14, 2026
34	USA Brooklyn Delicatessen	200 W 57th St	(646) 927-1604	Grade A	Sep 21, 2026
35	Whoopie Company	42 W 42nd St	(201) 546-0996	Grade A	Nov 28, 2023
36	Wolfnights	40 W 55th St	(646) 669-8070	Grade A	Jul 30, 2025

Street by street

W 42nd St 4

Casa Toscana 42 W 42nd St
Cheesesteaks by the Truffleist 42 W 42nd St
Shake Shack Bryant Park 120 W 42nd St
Whoopie Company 42 W 42nd St

Broadway 3

Pret a Manger 1700 Broadway
Pret a Manger 1756 Broadway
Subway 1400 Broadway

W 37th St 3

Cafe 37 47 W 37th St
Mel & Toast 252 W 37th St
The Picnic Basket 65 W 37th St

W 46th St 3

Holy Schnitzel 245 W 46th St
Matto Espresso 8 W 46th St
Subway 36 W 46th St

Rockefeller Plaza 2

Alidoro 1 Rockefeller Plaza
The Tipsy Baker 30 Rockefeller Plaza

W 56th St 2

Corporate Chef Cafe & Catering 50 W 56th St
Potbelly 46 W 56th St

One each: Broad Nosh Bagels on E 58th St, Potbelly on Fashion Ave, Broad Street Deli on Park Ave, The Shack - Cb8030 (Cb8040) on Penn Plaza, Subway on Vanderbilt Ave, Subway on W 26th St, Market Crates on W 33rd St, City Cafe on W 43rd St, Blake & Todd on W 47th St, Tsq Food Court on W 48th St, Subway on W 50th St, Wolfnights on W 55th St, USA Brooklyn Delicatessen on W 57th St.

Sandwich Shops in Midtown & Midtown South: questions

How many sandwich shops are in Midtown & Midtown South?: 36 filed as Sandwiches with at least one inspection, as of October 30, 2026. Owners pick their own label, so 10 more filed as Soups/Salads/Sandwiches and 22 more filed as Sandwiches/Salads/Mixed Buffet aren't in this count.
What is the best sandwich shop in Midtown & Midtown South?: 31 of 36 show an A, and the newest A went to Subway on October 22, 2026. That letter covers food safety at the last graded inspection. This file has no ratings or reviews, so we don't pick a favorite.
Which sandwich shops in Midtown & Midtown South have an A grade?: Alidoro, America Gourmet Food, Blake & Todd, Broad Nosh Bagels, Broad Street Deli, Cafe 37, Carve Unique Sandwiches, Casa Toscana, City Cafe, Corporate Chef Cafe & Catering, and 21 more.
Do any sandwich shops in Midtown & Midtown South have a B or C?: Yes. Gardenia Deli shows a B from June 5, 2023. Tsq Food Court shows a B from October 14, 2025.
Which street has the most sandwich shops in Midtown & Midtown South?: W 42nd St, with 4: Casa Toscana, Cheesesteaks by the Truffleist, Shake Shack Bryant Park, and Whoopie Company.
Are all 36 open right now?: The file has no hours, and a place can close months before it drops off. All of them have a phone number on file, so call before you go.

Keep looking

Sandwiches next door

Other labels in Midtown & Midtown South

All of Midtown & Midtown South

Citywide

Where this comes from

Names, addresses, phones, cuisine labels, grades and dates come from the DOHMH New York City Restaurant Inspection Results on NYC Open Data. The file behind this page is dated October 30, 2026, and its newest inspection is from October 29, 2026. We check for a new file every 24 hours. For the city's own lookup, use ABC Eats.