NYC Restaurant File

City data dated

24 Pizza Places in Upper West Side

Famous Original Ray's Pizza was inspected most recently, on October 26, 2026.

La Traviata 2 Pizzeria shows a B. 22 show an A. 1 has no letter right now.

9 of the 24 are on Broadway, and 8 more on Amsterdam Ave.

22 A 1 B 0 C 1 no letterOne tile per place. A health grade covers the last graded inspection: food handling, temperatures, cleaning, pests. Taste isn't part of it.
123456789101112131415161718192021222324
A B C no letter subway station, with its daytime linesNumbers match the table below.

The 24, A to Z

Pizza Places in Upper West Side, alphabetical
No.NameAddressPhoneGradeInspected
1Cheesy Pizza2640 Broadway(212) 662-5223Grade AMay 12, 2026
2Dbl Pie Pizza924 Amsterdam Ave(212) 222-4022Grade AApr 30, 2025
3Domino's Pizza #3685592 Columbus Ave(914) 337-3370Grade AAug 24, 2026
4Dreamer's Pizza II2345 Broadway(646) 407-6125Grade AOct 29, 2025
5Famous Famiglia734 Amsterdam Ave(212) 864-7193Grade ASep 16, 2026
6Famous Original Ray's Pizza462 Columbus Ave(212) 873-1134Grade AOct 26, 2026
7Freddie & Pepper's303 Amsterdam Ave(212) 799-2378Grade AJul 27, 2026
8Jet's Pizza728 Amsterdam Ave(646) 861-1605Grade AJul 15, 2025
9La Pizza Italia493 Amsterdam Ave(917) 899-0160No letterJun 29, 2026
10La Traviata 2 Pizzeria2753 Broadway(917) 602-1699Grade BAug 24, 2026
11La Vera Pizza2547 Broadway(212) 866-6500Grade ASep 1, 2026
12Little Italy Pizza214 W 92nd St(212) 594-7817Grade AApr 15, 2026
13Made in New York Pizza2563 Broadway(917) 544-7268Grade AMar 19, 2026
14Made in New York Pizza421 Amsterdam Ave(646) 484-6200Grade AJun 9, 2026
15Marinara483 Amsterdam Ave(917) 265-8780Grade AJan 15, 2026
16Marinara Pizza2578 Broadway(646) 949-0995Grade ASep 17, 2025
17Mimi's Pizza2393 Broadway(212) 970-8887Grade AAug 27, 2025
18Motorino510 Columbus Ave(917) 675-7581Grade ANov 7, 2025
19Papa John's Pizza896 Amsterdam Ave(212) 864-7272Grade AMar 23, 2026
20Patsy's Pizzeria61 W 74th St(212) 579-3000Grade AMay 28, 2025
21Pizza Pete's528 Columbus Ave(212) 787-3153Grade AOct 20, 2025
22Sal & Carmine Pizza2671 Broadway(212) 663-7651Grade AMay 11, 2026
23Salvatore S NY Pizza924 Columbus Ave(917) 529-0966Grade ADec 13, 2025
24Village Square Pizza - Upper West Side2479 Broadway(917) 369-0184Grade AJul 27, 2026

Street by street

Broadway 9

Amsterdam Ave 8

Columbus Ave 5

One each: Patsy's Pizzeria on W 74th St, Little Italy Pizza on W 92nd St.

Pizza Places in Upper West Side: questions

How many pizza places are in Upper West Side?
24 filed as Pizza with at least one inspection, as of October 30, 2026. Owners pick their own label, so 26 more filed as Italian aren't in this count.
What is the best pizza place in Upper West Side?
22 of 24 show an A, and the newest A went to Famous Famiglia on September 16, 2026. That letter covers food safety at the last graded inspection. This file has no ratings or reviews, so we don't pick a favorite.
Which pizza places in Upper West Side have an A grade?
Cheesy Pizza, Dbl Pie Pizza, Domino's Pizza #3685, Dreamer's Pizza II, Famous Famiglia, Famous Original Ray's Pizza, Freddie & Pepper's, Jet's Pizza, La Vera Pizza, Little Italy Pizza, and 12 more.
Do any pizza places in Upper West Side have a B or C?
Yes. La Traviata 2 Pizzeria shows a B from August 24, 2026.
Which street has the most pizza places in Upper West Side?
Broadway, with 9: Cheesy Pizza, Dreamer's Pizza II, La Traviata 2 Pizzeria, La Vera Pizza, Made in New York Pizza, Marinara Pizza, and 3 more.
Are all 24 open right now?
The file has no hours, and a place can close months before it drops off. All of them have a phone number on file, so call before you go.

Keep looking

Pizza next door

Other labels in Upper West Side

All of Upper West Side

Citywide

Where this comes from

Names, addresses, phones, cuisine labels, grades and dates come from the DOHMH New York City Restaurant Inspection Results on NYC Open Data. The file behind this page is dated October 30, 2026, and its newest inspection is from October 29, 2026. We check for a new file every 24 hours. For the city's own lookup, use ABC Eats.