How many pizza places are in Turtle Bay & East Midtown?

19 filed as Pizza with at least one inspection, as of October 30, 2026. Owners pick their own label, so 22 more filed as Italian aren't in this count.

What is the best pizza place in Turtle Bay & East Midtown?

16 of 19 show an A, and the newest A went to Xeno's Pizza on September 3, 2026. That letter covers food safety at the last graded inspection. This file has no ratings or reviews, so we don't pick a favorite.

Which pizza places in Turtle Bay & East Midtown have an A grade?

Best Pizza on 1st., Cassiano's Pizza, Domino's, La Trattoria Pizza, La Vera Pizza, La Vista Pizza, Little Italy Pizza, Marinara, My Pie, One Fifty Fresh Pizza, and 6 more.

Do any pizza places in Turtle Bay & East Midtown have a B or C?

Yes. Brooklyn Pizza Masters shows a B from April 9, 2026. Prova Pizza Bar shows a B from March 11, 2026.

Which street has the most pizza places in Turtle Bay & East Midtown?

1st Ave, with 5: Best Pizza on 1st., Brooklyn Pizza Masters, Domino's, Marinara, and Sofia Pizza Shoppe.

Are all 19 open right now?

The file has no hours, and a place can close months before it drops off. All of them have a phone number on file, so call before you go.

City data dated October 30, 2026

19 Pizza Places in Turtle Bay & East Midtown

Cassiano's Pizza was inspected most recently, on October 5, 2026.

Brooklyn Pizza Masters and Prova Pizza Bar show a B. 16 show an A. 1 has no letter right now.

5 of the 19 are on 1st Ave, and 4 more on 2nd Ave.

16 A 2 B 0 C 1 no letterOne tile per place. A health grade covers the last graded inspection: food handling, temperatures, cleaning, pests. Taste isn't part of it.

A B C no letter subway station, with its daytime linesNumbers match the table below.

The 19, A to Z

Pizza Places in Turtle Bay & East Midtown, alphabetical
No.	Name	Address	Phone	Grade	Inspected
1	Best Pizza on 1st.	1038 1st Ave	(212) 644-8400	Grade A	Jun 4, 2026
2	Brooklyn Pizza Masters	1055 1st Ave	(212) 203-3815	Grade B	Apr 9, 2026
3	Cassiano's Pizza	930 3rd Ave	(212) 755-2390	Grade A	Oct 5, 2026
4	Domino's	943 1st Ave	(347) 476-2809	Grade A	Dec 22, 2025
5	La Pizza Italia	959 2nd Ave	(917) 965-2248	Pending	Sep 4, 2026
6	La Trattoria Pizza	844 2nd Ave	(212) 682-5656	Grade A	Jan 21, 2026
7	La Vera Pizza	922 2nd Ave	(347) 514-2867	Grade A	Aug 24, 2026
8	La Vista Pizza	1099 2nd Ave	(646) 662-9797	Grade A	Apr 2, 2026
9	Little Italy Pizza	958 3rd Ave	(212) 355-3434	Grade A	Nov 12, 2024
10	Marinara	985 1st Ave	(917) 261-2147	Grade A	Mar 12, 2026
11	My Pie	690 Lexington Ave	(917) 371-0000	Grade A	Jun 4, 2026
12	One Fifty Fresh Pizza	151 E 43rd St	(718) 912-5126	Grade A	Sep 23, 2026
13	One Fifty Fresh Pizza	473 Lexington Ave	(212) 661-6221	Grade A	Feb 25, 2025
14	Prova Pizza Bar	89 E 42nd St	(212) 972-0385	Grade B	Mar 11, 2026
15	Slice Pizza	700 3rd Ave	(917) 442-0050	Grade A	Aug 11, 2026
16	Sofia Pizza Shoppe	989 1st Ave	(212) 888-8816	Grade A	Mar 10, 2026
17	Sofia Wine Bar	242 E 50th St	(212) 888-8660	Grade A	Aug 26, 2026
18	Stretch Pizza	157 E 53rd St	(917) 359-6466	Grade A	Jan 13, 2026
19	Xeno's Pizza	163 E 52nd St	(646) 952-0030	Grade A	Sep 3, 2026

Street by street

Lexington Ave 2

My Pie 690 Lexington Ave
One Fifty Fresh Pizza 473 Lexington Ave

One each: Prova Pizza Bar on E 42nd St, One Fifty Fresh Pizza on E 43rd St, Sofia Wine Bar on E 50th St, Xeno's Pizza on E 52nd St, Stretch Pizza on E 53rd St.

Pizza Places in Turtle Bay & East Midtown: questions

How many pizza places are in Turtle Bay & East Midtown?: 19 filed as Pizza with at least one inspection, as of October 30, 2026. Owners pick their own label, so 22 more filed as Italian aren't in this count.
What is the best pizza place in Turtle Bay & East Midtown?: 16 of 19 show an A, and the newest A went to Xeno's Pizza on September 3, 2026. That letter covers food safety at the last graded inspection. This file has no ratings or reviews, so we don't pick a favorite.
Which pizza places in Turtle Bay & East Midtown have an A grade?: Best Pizza on 1st., Cassiano's Pizza, Domino's, La Trattoria Pizza, La Vera Pizza, La Vista Pizza, Little Italy Pizza, Marinara, My Pie, One Fifty Fresh Pizza, and 6 more.
Do any pizza places in Turtle Bay & East Midtown have a B or C?: Yes. Brooklyn Pizza Masters shows a B from April 9, 2026. Prova Pizza Bar shows a B from March 11, 2026.
Which street has the most pizza places in Turtle Bay & East Midtown?: 1st Ave, with 5: Best Pizza on 1st., Brooklyn Pizza Masters, Domino's, Marinara, and Sofia Pizza Shoppe.
Are all 19 open right now?: The file has no hours, and a place can close months before it drops off. All of them have a phone number on file, so call before you go.

Keep looking

Pizza next door

Other labels in Turtle Bay & East Midtown

All of Turtle Bay & East Midtown

Citywide

Where this comes from

Names, addresses, phones, cuisine labels, grades and dates come from the DOHMH New York City Restaurant Inspection Results on NYC Open Data. The file behind this page is dated October 30, 2026, and its newest inspection is from October 29, 2026. We check for a new file every 24 hours. For the city's own lookup, use ABC Eats.